St Barth vs Anguilla: the summary
St Barth and Anguilla are two remote, hard-to-reach islands in the Caribbean that offer unique experiences for travelers. Whether you seek luxury, tranquility, or adventure, choosing between these two paradises can be challenging. This guide compares the accessibility, culture, landscapes, activities, and costs of St Barth and Anguilla to help you decide which island is the perfect destination for your next vacation.
St Barth vs Anguilla: two remote and hard to reach islands
Best way to access St Barth
Reaching St Barth involves a bit of an adventure. Most visitors fly into Princess Juliana International Airport in St Maarten and then take a short, scenic flight or ferry ride to St Barth. The Gustaf III Airport in St Barth is known for its dramatic approach and small runway, adding an element of excitement to your journey.
How to go to Anguilla
Anguilla is typically accessed via a flight to St Maarten or Puerto Rico, followed by a ferry or small plane transfer. The Clayton J. Lloyd International Airport accommodates smaller aircraft, and the island’s main ferry terminal connects to St Maarten, making it relatively easy to reach despite its remote location.
Ways to go from St Barth to Anguilla and vice versa
Traveling between St Barth and Anguilla is straightforward. You can take a ferry or a private boat, or charter a small plane for a quick flight. This flexibility allows for easy island-hopping, making it possible to explore both destinations in one trip.
Cultural differences between St Barth and Anguilla
St Barth is close to French culture with a Caribbean twist
The island’s culinary scene is a testament to this fusion, offering exquisite French cuisine infused with local Caribbean flavors. Visitors can indulge in gourmet dishes at chic bistros and fine-dining restaurants, savoring fresh seafood, buttery pastries, and vibrant Creole spices. The beverage scene is equally enticing, featuring fine French wines, tropical cocktails, and locally produced rhum agricole. French is the predominant language, adding an authentic European charm to the island, though English is widely spoken due to its international clientele. This unique cultural blend creates a sophisticated yet relaxed atmosphere, making St Barth a captivating destination for those seeking both elegance and island allure.
Anguilla is more international due to its UK ties and its neighbors
Anguilla boasts a rich cultural tapestry that reflects its international flair, largely due to its historical ties with the UK and its proximity to other diverse Caribbean islands. This British overseas territory presents a blend of traditions and influences, most notably in its culinary scene, where you can savor a fusion of Caribbean flavors and British classics, alongside international cuisine from nearby islands. Rum punch and locally brewed beers are popular, but you’ll also find fine teas and British ales. English is the official language, spoken with a charming Caribbean accent, but the island’s multicultural environment means you may also hear Spanish, French, and Creole. This melting pot of influences creates a unique and inviting atmosphere for visitors from around the globe.
Anguilla and St Barth: two islands with amazing landscapes
Main landscapes in St Barth
St Barth features rugged terrain with lush hills and dramatic coastlines. The island’s natural beauty includes pristine beaches, scenic hiking trails, and stunning vistas that provide breathtaking views of the Caribbean Sea.
Main landscapes in Anguilla
Anguilla’s landscape is flatter and more arid compared to St Barth. The island is known for its white sandy beaches, crystal-clear waters, and low-lying terrain, creating a serene and picturesque environment perfect for relaxation.
Beaches : both Anguilla and St Barth have amazing beaches
Anguilla has deserted heaven like beaches with a view on St Maarten
Anguilla boasts some of the most beautiful and secluded beaches in the Caribbean, often with views of St Maarten. These tranquil spots offer an ideal setting for relaxation and solitude.
St Barth has beaches with topless options and mountain views
St Barth is famous for its luxurious beaches where topless sunbathing is common. The island’s beaches are often framed by mountains, providing a stunning backdrop for sunbathing and watersports.
Activities in Anguilla vs St Barth: two different vibes to cater your mood
Anguilla is a very calm island with little nightlife and activities
Anguilla is perfect for those seeking tranquility. The island offers limited nightlife and activities, focusing instead on peaceful beach days, snorkeling, and enjoying the natural surroundings.
St Barth is more active with a bit of nightlife and lots of watersports
St Barth provides a more dynamic atmosphere with various watersports, upscale shopping, and a vibrant nightlife. The island caters to those looking for both relaxation and adventure.
Read also: Caribbean Yacht Charter: Everything You Should Know
What should you do if you visit Anguilla and St Barth?
Must-do and must-see in Anguilla
– Relax on Shoal Bay East, one of the world’s most beautiful beaches.
– Visit the Heritage Collection Museum to learn about Anguilla’s history.
– Enjoy a boat trip to Sandy Island, a tiny cay with excellent snorkeling.
Must-do and must see in St Barth
– Explore Gustavia, the island’s charming capital, known for its shopping and dining.
– Visit Colombier Beach, accessible only by hiking or boat.
– Experience the vibrant nightlife at one of the island’s chic beach clubs.
Which is cheaper to visit: Anguilla or St Barth?
Both islands are known for their luxury and can be expensive. However, Anguilla tends to be slightly more affordable than St Barth, particularly regarding dining and accommodation. St Barhs, with its high-end resorts and upscale restaurants, often attracts a wealthier crowd.
Chartering a yacht: the best way to visit Anguilla, St Barh and/or St Maarten in a few days
Chartering a yacht is a fantastic way to explore these islands. It allows you to experience the beauty and diversity of the Caribbean at your own pace, offering flexibility and comfort. You can easily hop between Anguilla, St Barth, and St Maarten, enjoying the best each island has to offer.
Conclusion
Both St Barth and Anguilla offer unique and unforgettable experiences. Your choice depends on your preferences: opt for St Barth if you seek a lively atmosphere with plenty of activities and a touch of French elegance, or choose Anguilla for a serene, laid-back vacation with some of the Caribbean’s most stunning beaches. Better yet, if time allows, visit both islands to experience the best of both worlds.
Read also: 10 UNUSUAL MEDITERRANEAN CHARTER DESTINATIONS
FAQ
St. Barth is generally more expensive than Anguilla due to its ultra-luxurious accommodations, high-end dining, and upscale shopping options. While both islands cater to a wealthy clientele, the cost of staying, dining, and shopping in St. Barth tends to be higher than in Anguilla.
Anguilla is often considered to have better beaches than St. Barth, boasting pristine, powdery white sands and crystal-clear turquoise waters. Its beaches, such as Shoal Bay East and Rendezvous Bay, are renowned for their natural beauty and tranquility.
St. Barth, a French-speaking island, reflects a strong French influence in its culture, cuisine, and lifestyle, marked by its chic, upscale ambiance and European flair. In contrast, Anguilla, an English-speaking British Overseas Territory, has a more laid-back, Caribbean vibe with a strong emphasis on local music, particularly reggae and calypso, and a rich tradition of boat racing.
Anguilla is generally better for families due to its more relaxed atmosphere, family-friendly resorts, and calm, shallow beaches that are ideal for children. St. Barth, while luxurious and beautiful, tends to cater more to adults and offers fewer amenities specifically designed for families.
Visa requirements for St. Barth depend on your nationality. U.S., Canadian, EU, and many other nationals do not need a visa for stays up to 90 days. However, a valid passport and proof of onward travel are required. For longer stays or other nationalities, it’s best to check specific requirements with the French embassy or consulate.
Visa requirements for Anguilla vary depending on your nationality. Citizens of the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, and many European Union countries do not need a visa for stays up to 90 days. Visitors from countries that do require a visa must obtain it in advance from a British Embassy or Consulate, as Anguilla is a British Overseas Territory. Always check the latest entry requirements before travel.
